Death
The problem with this mentality, as I figured out after reading Solomon's chapter on death, is that it seems to infer that life is nothing, it is insignificant. Solomon has a problem with this because he wants to advocate the richeness of one's life as one's primary focus, not the insignificant of one's life. Being an existentialist, it doesn't surprise me that Solomon thinks this way. Existentialism, as I see it, recognizes the cosmic insignificance of one's life, but calls upon individuals to do something with their life and create its meaning, their own meaning.
Because of the cynic of me, I've often missed taking a look at the social aspect of death. How will I be remembered? Who will take care of my family? If I have kids, what's going to happen to them? What's more scary, is recognizing that the world goes on without me. Will anyone remember me? How long will it take for people to forget about me? Will the world be okay without me? Then there is the issue of my body's disposal. Should I donate it to scientific research? Should I allow my organs to be used to save other people's lives? Do I want to be buried or cremated?
Even with these questions, death should not be feared. Fearing something inevitable is self-defeating. After reading Solomon's chapter on death, my mindset is that death may be nothing from my perspective, but to those around me, and to those whom I have loved and will love, I hope my death is something to them. Solomon says it best,
The fear of death easily presents itself as a metaphysical or logical perplexity, as a dread of the unknown, as a confrontation with nothingness. The truth, I think, is much less flattering. We worry about the pain of dying, of the pain that precedes dying. We vainly worry about the disposition of our bodies after death. We worry about the people we care for, but then we also worry that they will be fine without our care, indeed, that they will not even remember us without our constant, even if kindly, reminders. The idea that death is nothing, to may not be so much a matter of metaphysics as an awkward sense of absence. Put in the least flattering way, we might say that my death is a bad thing because it deprives the universe of me. I picture the world without me, like Sartre's characters in No Exist. I see them talk about me, laugh about me, pity me. I watch someone date and marry my wife, raise my children, refute my books. Or worse, I see that they ignore me. Death may be nothing, but it is a nothing that hurts.
Comments
Nagel has an article on death as well that I need to reread. But I recall that he also doesn't like the argument that says: I didn't exist before my birth and didn't have a problem and the same goes for after death. The problem is that there is a relevant difference between the two. Before your birth, you were deprived of nothing. After death, you are deprived of life. In any event, the argument doesn't help console us for very long, if at all. But perhaps nothing can.
For me, before birth, I had nothing: no emotions, no ambitions, no family. During life, I have all of these things and more. After death, it's all gone.
I love Solomon's last line too. I'll be keeping that in the back of my head for quite sometime.
How interesting! Have you seen the movie Hogfather? I love how they portray Death in that movie (similar to Sandman).
Funny, because I cling to the idea of reincarnation. I totally agree that saying death is no big deal means that life is no big deal. Well to me it is. Lama Surya Das puts it this way - "we might find the idea of reincarnation surprising, but it's no more surprising than being born in the first place. What a miracle".
I'm not really into the idea of reincarnation lol. I see it as another denial of death, but that depends on what one means by reincarnation.