Einstein and Religion
I am a deeply religious nonbeliever - this is a somewhat new kind of religion.
-Albert Einstein
The religiosity of Albert Einstein has been debated for quite some time. Someone say he believe in God and was a traditional theists. Others say, he wasn't a traditional theist, and some even say he was an atheist. It seems Einstein wasn't an atheist, but he wasn't a traditional theist at all. Einstein was a pantheist. In a recently discovered letter written to a philosopher friend, Einstein states that Bible is "childish." Perhaps this letter with finally show everyone that Einstein wasn't a traditional theist at all.
Einstein letter calls Bible ‘pretty childish’
Famous scientist also dismisses belief in God as product of human weakness
LONDON - Albert Einstein: arch rationalist or scientist with a spiritual core?
A letter being auctioned in London this week adds more fuel to the long-simmering debate about the Nobel Prize-winning physicist's religious views. In the note, written the year before his death, Einstein dismissed the idea of God as the product of human weakness and the Bible as "pretty childish."
The letter, handwritten in German, is being sold by Bloomsbury Auctions on Thursday and is expected to fetch between $12,000 and $16,000.
Einstein, who helped unravel the mysteries of the universe with his theory of relativity, expressed complex and arguably contradictory views on faith, perceiving a universe suffused with spirituality while rejecting organized religion.
The letter up for sale, written to philosopher Eric Gutkind in January 1954, suggests his views on religion did not mellow with age.
In it, Einstein said that "the word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honorable but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish."
"For me," he added, "the Jewish religion like all other religions is an incarnation of the most childish superstitions."
Addressing the idea that the Jews are God's chosen people, Einstein wrote that "the Jewish people to whom I gladly belong and with whose mentality I have a deep affinity have no different quality for me than all other people. As far as my experience goes, they are also no better than other human groups, although they are protected from the worst cancers by a lack of power. Otherwise I cannot see anything 'chosen' about them."
Bloomsbury spokesman Richard Caton said the auction house was "100 percent certain" of the letter's authenticity. It is being offered at auction for the first time, by a private vendor.
Quirky beliefs
John Brooke, emeritus professor of science and religion at Oxford University, said the letter lends weight to the notion that "Einstein was not a conventional theist" — although he was not an atheist, either.
"Like many great scientists of the past, he is rather quirky about religion, and not always consistent from one period to another," Brooke said.
Born to a Jewish family in Germany in 1879, Einstein said he went through a devout phase as a child before beginning to question conventional religion at the age of 12.
In later life, he expressed a sense of wonder at the universe and its mysteries — what he called a "cosmic religious feeling" — and famously said: "Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind."
But he also said: "I do not believe in the God of theology who rewards good and punishes evil. My God created laws that take care of that. His universe is not ruled by wishful thinking, but by immutable laws."
Brooke said Einstein believed that "there is some kind of intelligence working its way through nature. But it is certainly not a conventional Christian or Judaic religious view."
Einstein's most famous legacy is the special theory of relativity, which makes the point that a large amount of energy could be released from a tiny amount of matter, as expressed in the equation e=mc2 (energy equals mass times the speed of light squared). The theory changed the face of physics, allowing scientists to make predictions about space and paving the way for nuclear power and the atomic bomb.
Einstein's musings on science, war, peace and God helped make him world famous, and his scientific legacy prompted Time magazine to name him its Person of the 20th Century.
Comments
And I don't see how there is a debate at all. Some people just don't understand that scientists and philosophers like Einstein often borrow religious language to describe their thoughts and feelings. It doesn't mean they share your metaphysical religious beliefs.
And I would consider Einstein an atheist simply because I tend to define an atheist as a non-theist. ;)
Me too. No problem :)
"Naturalistic pantheism places little emphasis on the concept of God. This raises the concern that it is really no longer pantheism at all, but something more like "spiritual naturalism" or "feel-good atheism". After all, these critics ask, if you remove the concept of God from your philosophy, what is the purpose of using the term "pantheism?" It is charged that the etymology of the word reveals it is inappropriately used in describing an anti-theist philosophy. In answer to this objection, naturalistic pantheists maintain that the "pan-" prefix modifies the "-theism" suffix to such an extent that pantheism in fact has little to do with traditional theism.
"Critics regard this modern pantheism as simply a more reverent and naturalistic form of atheism, since this unusual conception of God is seen as bending the traditional definition so far as to make it meaningless. In the view of some modern adherents, this objection to using the historical term "pantheism" for the naturalistic interpretation is essentially valid, and these adherents usually admit that the term is maintained only for the sake of convenience."
One common interpretation of this sort of pantheism is basically spiritual atheism. And Einstein seems much closer to this than to any other notion of pantheism.
The reason that people point to Einstein's spirituality is usually to make a point about belief in God through appeal to person. It can be a simple fallacy - "Einstein believed in God - Einstein was smart - so belief in God is smart" or a refutation of the appeals to person used by some antitheists "most scientists are atheists" meets "well Einstein believed in God" or "religious people are stupid" meets "So Einstein was stupid?" It's a nonsensical argument on all sides. Trot out Einstein's spirituality, and anyone else can bring up Stephen Hawking's lack thereof. Bring up the atheism of some modern mathematician, and someone else can remind you of the fanatical religiosity of Isaac Newton. Appeal to person doesn't work - scientists, mathematicians, and thinkers have all held varied ideas about the existence and nature of God(s).
Pantheism is not atheism though. It is a very radically different idea of God, but it is a God-concept. Pantheists don't deify the universe. Rather, they say that everything is part of an abstract, impersonal God - that "God" is the sum total of existence. It's quite beautiful, really. Theism is not limited to belief in a supernatural or personal God.